We have made the decision to send M to school <insert dramatic chord here>.
It’s a huge change and not one we take lightly, but because I’ve been such an advocate of unschooling, its one i wanted to explain a little …
Anne & I have a vision for the type of homeschooling we embarked on as being exciting, stimulating and most importantly full of connection with each other, our children and a supportive community. We love the unschooling catch cry, ‘the world is our classroom’, and wanted to create an environment where our kids could go on a journey of self discovery and truly engage with this amazing, complex world on their terms.
High expectations definitely, but there were days when we seemed to get close. Well, perhaps not days, but moments—times of connection and joy that was enough to make us feel vindicated in our decision.
However as we took stock over the new year’s break we realised that those moments have become fewer and fewer, with longer stretches in between. I’ve mentioned the challenges we had over a year ago with the birth of our third child in a post called Adventures in Crappy Parenting — the fact is, between juggling the needs of our three kids, ourselves and dealing with an ongoing health issue, we never really got our mojo back from that point.
As a result homeschooling for M (who is turning 9 in a couple of weeks) has moved a long, long way from our vision. While Z (who is 4) is the sort of child who enjoys staying at home and inventing new things to do and play with, M is the sort who thrives on new experiences, adventures and people to engage with.
Around December we chatted to M about what she wanted to do in the coming year . She expressed the same interests in new experiences and being exposed to more options each day, rather than having to generate things by herself. I found myself making promises of the sorts of fun things we’d do, the activities Anne & I would organise, the initiatives we’d make… all the while having a funny sense of dejavu. It was a day later that I remembered we’d made similar commitments in 2009, and had implemented almost none of them.
Still we thought, there must be ways to make unschooling work better for us… One of the options that grabbed Anne’s imagination was unschooling on the road, and embarking on some big travels. This would have been wonderful for M in many ways, but the reality is we have to engage in long negotiations to get Z going for a walk, let alone setting off on major trips. Still its something we explored for a long time, and well might try in the future…
Then we considered moving to a place with more homeschoolers so we could plug into things more (in our current location there are literally a handful of homeschoolers). This was appealing also, but it still felt that time in between such activities were long days, where even when M wanted to do something interesting or new we were having to put her off while we juggled the needs of her siblings, health issues, our home business and our own needs.
So after much consideration we have decided to move to Brisbane and try out school. We chose carefully, selecting Brisbane Independent School (BIS) (at the time of posting their website was down, but there’s a little about them on wikipedia) which is based on a democratic model, has a total of about 50 students and similar values to ours. But as interesting as BIS is, I still must admit to initially feeling like a failure after we made the decision.
I’ve read about single parents unschooling 4 plus kids; even others who work part time as well… so the question came crashing into our ego’s: ‘why couldn’t we make it work?’
After a little while i realised how useless that question was… the fact is, our homeschooling experience has not been living up to our expectations or desires since the birth of H, and when we looked at what M’s life experience was, the word that came to mind was ‘uninspiring’.
She’d raised the option of school a few times in the last couple of years, and each time we’ve shifted what we’re doing, trying out more dance classes, hiring some help to look after the boys so we can do some more one on one, but they were often short lived and still never managed to really meet her needs…
This time, for the first time, we raised the idea. M quickly expressed that she wanted to try school but had three main concerns:
1. she wanted a fair bit of choice, for example she didn’t want to have to sit in a classroom all day if it was a beautiful day outside.
2. she was concerned about bullying
3. she would miss us and wanted to see us during the day still
We were surprised that she’d thought this through enough to have a list ready but explained that the BIS option best addresses each of her concerns. So for example we intend to be active in the school community and help out at the school itself regularly (which is encouraged); the small group plus high ratio of conscious adults would make bullying unlikely and/ or able to be addressed; and she will have more autonomy and choice than in traditional schools.
Since then, she has been absolutely ecstatic about the decision. Nervous, but very excited.
That’s helped a lot. It’s really been how We’ve gone from focusing on those feelings of being a failure, to saying that this is our current reality and this decision is the best way forward for our family now.
When i think on those terms I must admit to feeling massive relief. It’s been a hard couple of years, and I know things will change, but in the meantime doing BIS feels like the best way of reaching our goals of creating an exciting, stimulating and connected environment for our family.
Do i regret unschooling to this point? Definitely not. We’ve had some wonderful times and I think it’s really been wonderful to provide M with the space to get to know herself without many external pressures. I feel now at the age of 9, she can approach school with more confidence and self awareness. It will no doubt present challenges, but frankly the way we were homeschooling had its own set of challenges too.
Can we still unschool while M goes to school? I know people talk about doing this, and of course at home we will provide the same freedom and support to her as always, but i do feel things change significantly with school… I’ll write about this more in the future.
Might we unschool in the future? Yes, we just want to do what’s the best for our family and find the ways to meet our respective needs and live the most connected & joyful life possible… the strategies to achieve that will change with our situation. Right now we’re not making long term plans, but we’re confident that BIS is the best next step forward.
What’s the capital of Estonia? I’d have to google that, but that question probably means that I’ve written enough for now…